I’ve been trying to get better at typing, since I’m on a computer largely for the majority of my time now. I’ve spent a lot of time with QWERTY but I wanted to have a more comfortable experience, especially since I never really learned to touch type properly. My hybrid WASD + hunt and peck mode of typing now translated into immediate wrist pain.
I actually have a presentation on RSI and Carpal Tunnel that I made in elementary after I played too many video games, so this is not new. I managed to get away from typing for a while, but the world is becoming increasingly digital, save various control schemes (dials and buttons).
Colemak-DH is one of the “popular” alternative layouts given it’s similarity to QWERTY and relative ease of learning compared to something like Hands-Down-Promethium – which requires a custom split keyboard and thumb cluster. The shortcuts are in the same places, the keyboard only has minor changes to spread the load out from having everything on the left hand.
I took the better part of a month learning how to touch type, and switched from QWERTY more or less immediately. This wasn’t a fun process. It took a gargantuan effort to find keys and type out a single paragraph. I left the first week with a headache.
The following months were better, having moved from 10 words a minute all the way to 30 – still not the best, although writing was becoming less of a pain along the way. I could do most of my tasks without issue at this point, although I was still getting used to having both hands on the keyboard at the same time now – it felt a bit cramped.
I then switched to a split-keyboard design, moving the shift key onto a thumb cluster, as well as integrating layers into my typing. This was another significant hurdle, though I will say not needing to only use my thumb for space is significant – but having to move my thumb under my palm to hit a key is significantly more painful than not having a key available at all.
I redesigned the keyboard to shift the inner thumb cluster further outwards – and ended up spending another month learning CAD to fix some of the issues with the initial design. I now have space, shift, backspace/delete on the thumb clusters – which means I can do all of my basic typing without needing to reach over to hit a key.
I reached a steady 55 WPM on both layouts – slower than my prior max speed. That said, lack of layers means that I was already trying to type symbols at an astonishing 15 wpm when programming on ANSI QWERTY – compared to 30 wpm on matrix Colemak-DH with layers.
I strongly recommend that anyone with an inclination to use a keyboard all day to learn touch typing – and if at all possible, think about if you want to switch layouts. Gallium/Colemak-DH are some of the best contenders right now for ease of use/learning. The switch won’t make you faster, but it will make you be able to type for longer, more comfortably. You should avoid it if you are comfortable at your current pace and working conditions – but if you ever have wrist pain, there are options.
(Stenography is better for raw speed and comfort – but learning that is an entire profession that takes years, not two months of casual interest.)